BMW Automaker Web Site Banned From Google For Sp*mming Search Engines

BBC NEWS breaks search engine sp*m news, while this story has been making the rounds of SEO/SEM forums and newsletters for the past couple of days, since Matt Cutts posted about it in his SEO blog on February 4th:

http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/ramping-up-on-international-webspam/

... at first there was little international press (and none in the US) on the issue, but the BBC story has started a landslide of news and commentary on search engine sp*m by major corporations. It is also likely to brand all SEO's universally as bad guy Black Hat SEO's and ignore the good guy White Hats. Legitimate techniques and resulting ranking improvements rarely gain the attention given the bad guys.

I've reported major Fortune 500 corporations for sp*mming through the Google sp*m reporting link a half dozen times over the past year and am happy to see actions being taken against the worst offenders.

http://www.google.com/contact/spamreport.html

BMW Germany targeting the term "Used Cars" on it's new car site using javascript redirects is a blatant abuse of doorway pages and cloaking for inappropriate search phrases.

Cutts shows screen captures of the BMW offense, but mentions only peripherally that Ricoh.de would be banned as well, then sends a direct message to a separate US automaker at the end of his sp*mming post, telling them that they'll be re-included following a 30 day ban for similar offenses they've apparently cleaned up from their European site.

Search engine sp*mming is certainly not limited to Europe, although one of my complaints to the Google sp*m reporting link is for a European company site, which 5 months after reporting, STILL ranks #1 for a highly competitive phrase in US results. They use different search engine sp*mming techniques employing invisible code full of links, H1 tags and keyword phrases which are intended for surfers with javascript turned off - the < noscript> tag. Search engines see this invisible text, while surfers don't as it is buried in the HTML code.

The home page of one site I reported for sp*mming is made up entirely of images and has no hope of ranking well for any search phrase from the home page due to complete lack of text, so they may feel justified in using < noscript> tags to rank for an admittedly appropriate search phrase, by using a technique recognized as search engine sp*mming. When any large corporation sees fit to use sp*mming techniques, it encourages EVERYONE to do the same, simply because they feel justified for whatever reason suits them, reasonable or not.

This lesser known technique, filling < noscript> tags with H1, tags, keyword phrase hypertext links, and invisible text within tags, is effective and is used by many sp*mmers. I believe that smaller offenders would be instantly banned if this were discovered in use on their site, even if they were using appropriate keyword phrases for their topic or site subject. The big boys should be penalized as well.

I'll feel better when ALL search engine sp*mming techniques are penalized equally, regardless of the technique used or terms targeted, or any rationalized justifications. When that happens universally, then sp*mmers will stop sp*mming the search engines. But not until then.

This BMW case has become high profile for a major offense and is likely to gain attention in hurriedly called meetings in boardrooms of major corporations, with webmasters and marketing departments in attendance. "Are we doing this!" CEO's will rage at befuddled webmasters or in-house SEO's. But until ALL methods of search sp*m are penalized publicly, those lesser offenses will continue at all levels - especially large companies with more to gain (when they get away with sp*mming) and to lose (when they get caught and exposed/banned).

Copyright February 7, 2006 Mike Banks Valentine

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/4685750.stm

Mike Banks Valentine blogs on Search Engine developments from http://RealitySEO.com and can be contacted for ethical SEO work at: http://www.seoptimism.com/SEO_Contact.htm He runs web content distribution site at: http://Publish101.com